Randy Choate, the Rays soul lefty in the pen for most of the 2010 season, signed a two year $2.5 million contact with the Florida Marlins. This humble writer has mixed feelings about this deal.
Let me explain: when Choate was on, he was on. And though he didn’t throw lights out stuff, he certainly was a welcome addition to the right handed dominant bullpen. Choate ended the season with a 4-3 record with a 4.23 ERA in 85 appearances. Not stellar, but not horrific.
Conversely, when he was off, he was terrible. Does anyone remember Randy “Choke” and the 14+ ERA at the beginning of the season?
Being the soul lefty in the bullpen for the majority of the season found Choate as a very depended and valuable commodity. Yet to say that his performance and numbers were staggering would be a bit of an over-inflated statement. Sure, he did well facing one or two hitters every night, but is his performance worth the $2.5 million he’d be receiving with the Marlins? Also, with up and coming lefty Jake McGee probably joining the ranks along with any of their pre Spring Training acquisitions, will Choate even be missed?
Choate, Wheeler, Cormier, represented stability in knowing that they were there. And knowing they were there was a nice feeling. But, are we Rays fans more worried about them being gone or are we more concerned about the unknown?
I’d have to think that with prudent decision making and a healthy eye on the cheaper, quality players in the market (not to mention the pitchers in the pen that aren’t going anywhere) the Rays will be able to compensate for the loss of Choate and the potential loss of Wheeler and Cormier.
Now with the loss of Benoit and the potential losses of Balfour and Soriano who are both free agents? That’s a different story.
Update
This just in. The Rays have either just signed, or are close to signing reliever Joel Peralta. In the five years that he has been in the big leagues, Peralta has put up numbers eerily similar to Wheeler. It’s safe to say the Rays have found Wheeler’s replacement and/or doppelganger.